REGIONAL CARBON PRICING INITIATIVES
Two cap-and-trade programs are currently operating in the United States: The REGIONAL GREENHOUSE GAS INITIATIVE (or RGGI for short)in the Northeast and Mid-Atlantic, and the WESTERN CLIMATE INITIATIVE, which involves California and Québec. The TRANSPORTATION AND CLIMATE INITIATIVE, an additional cap-and-trade program for transportation fuels, is also under development in the RGGI region.
For more on how cap-and-trade programs work, visit our Why Price Carbon? page
Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative
Connecticut, Delaware, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New York, Rhode Island, Vermont, New Jersey. Under consideration: Pennsylvania, Virginia.
In-state electricity generation
$5.61/short ton CO₂ (December 2019)
- 2005 Initial Program Design: 188 to 169 million short tons CO₂e, 2009-2018 (10% reduction)
- 2012 Program Review: 91 to 77 million short tons CO₂e, 2014-2020 (15% reduction)
- 2017 Program Review: 75 to 53 million short tons CO₂e, 2021-2030 (30% reduction)
The Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative is the longest-operating cap-and-trade program for greenhouse gases in the United States, reaching full implementation in 2009. Since implementation, the emissions cap has been adjusted downward multiple times, with 2020 cap levels constituting one-third of the cap level in 2009. As of 2018, emissions from RGGI power plants were 47% lower than 2008 levels, although a majority of these reductions have been attributed to factors other than RGGI.
To date, RGGI auctions have sold nearly all allowances at government auction for between $1.86 and $7.50 per short ton of CO₂, for a total of $3.4 billion in revenue that states have largely invested in energy efficiency and renewable energy programs. Studies find that each control period of RGGI (2009-2011, 2012-2014, 2017) has added between $1.3 and $1.6 billion in economic benefits to the region from reduced energy costs. In addition, the program has generated almost $6 billion in net co-benefits from reducing co-pollutants, leading to improved public health and productivity.
In 2017, RGGI states agreed to extend the program through 2030, with a cap that decreases 30% between 2021 and 2030. Price containment mechanisms are designed to keep allowance prices between $6 and $13 per short ton of CO₂ beginning in 2021, increasing 7% each year after. Periodic reviews are scheduled to assess oversupply of allowances in the program, which could lead to further cap adjustments in the coming decade.
The Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI) was the first mandatory cap-and-trade program in the U.S., intended to reduce emissions in the electricity sector. In the absence of federal regulations, former New York Governor George Pataki issued a call to other governors in the region to design a mandatory program to limit emissions from the electric sector in 2003. On December 20th, 2005, the governors of Connecticut, Delaware, Maine, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, and Vermont announced an agreement to implement RGGI, outlined in a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU). In 2007, Maryland, Massachusetts, and Rhode Island joined the initiative by signing the MOU.
The program was designed so that individual states needed to enact legislation or regulations based on the RGGI model rule, released in 2006, to establish individual CO2 Budget Trading Programs. These programs limit carbon dioxide emissions, issue allowances, and establish participation in regional auctions for allowances. The first multi-state auctions occurred in September and December of 2008, and the first compliance period began on January 1, 2009. The original cap was set to approximately 188 million short tons of carbon dioxide for the entire region and was designed to decline by 2.5% annually between 2015 and 2018 — aiming to achieve a 10% reduction in emissions from power plants by 2019. The states had originally planned to give away the allowances to generators, who could then trade them, following the European Union’s Emissions Trading System (EU ETS). But advocacy by a coalition of environmental groups convinced the states that selling the allowances and using the funds for clean energy and other state programs made more sense.
Following a shift in administration, New Jersey formally withdrew from RGGI in 2012, but rejoined the program in 2020. In October of 2019, Governor Wolf announced plans for Pennsylvania to join RGGI. Virginia is also considering joining RGGI, following a climate-friendly swing in the legislature in 2019.
Read More About State-Level Action in the RGGI Region on our SCPN Page
Read our Latest Coverage on RGGI
In a landmark decision last week, Virginia passed the Clean Economy Act in both the House and Senate. The legislation sets the state to join the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI), a regional cap-and-invest program for the electric sector in...
With COP25 currently underway, market-based approaches to emissions reductions have been a major topic of negotiations among almost 200 countries, as they work to finalize rules under Article 6 of the Paris Agreement. On November 4th, the United States formally...
Yesterday, Pennsylvania Governor Tom Wolf signed an executive order directing the Department of Environmental Protection to join the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI). The state’s entry into RGGI marks the program’s largest expansion since its inception more than a decade...
Regional Cap and Trade: Lessons from the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative and Western Climate Initiative
TWO LARGE CAP-AND-TRADE SYSTEMS for carbon dioxide emissions (CO2) exist in the U.S. — the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI) that currently covers ten Northeast and Mid-Atlantic states; and the Western Climate Initiative (WCI), which now includes California and the...
Transportation and Climate Initiative
Under consideration — Implementation expected in 2022
Connecticut, Delaware, Maryland, Massachusetts, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Vermont, Virginia, Washington DC. Observers: Maine, New York
On-road transportation (gasoline and diesel)
The Transportation and Climate Initiative (TCI) is a regional cap-and-invest program under consideration for transportation emissions in the Northeast and Mid-Atlantic. The program would require fuel distributors to purchase permits according to the consumption of their product in participating states, raising revenue for clean transportation investment.
Most TCI states signed a letter of intent in December 2018 to undertake a thorough and expedient process to design and negotiate the program. A year later, in December 2019, the states released preliminary modeling results and a draft MOU, suggesting that the states are considering a cap reduction of 20% to 25% between 2022 and 2032. A final MOU is expected in the Spring of 2020, following additional public input and analysis. At that time, each TCI jurisdiction will decide whether to sign the final MOU and participate in the regional program, anticipated to launch in 2022.
New Hampshire has formally withdrawn from the TCI process, while New York and Maine remain in observer status of the TCI program. Many of the TCI states already participate in the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative. The two programs combined have the potential to cover a majority of the region’s emissions, although the ambition of the TCI program is yet to be determined.
Read More About State-Level Action in the TCI Region on our SCPN Page
Read our Latest Coverage on TCI
The Transportation and Climate Initiative (TCI) states have released both a draft MOU and multiple policy scenarios for a regional cap-and-invest program on transportation emissions. The release comes almost exactly a year after they first signed a statement of intent...
This webinar is part of the State Carbon Pricing Network’s Deep Dive webinar series Each month, we explore a carbon pricing topic in depth, bringing in experts and pushing forward the conversation. Transportation is currently expensive, inefficient and highly polluting. Passenger cars...
Over the next few months, the Transportation and Climate Initiative (TCI) will be forecasting the impacts of setting up a cap-and-trade system for transportation in the Northeast and Mid-Atlantic states. This forecast will be critical to the GHG reduction targets...
Western Climate Initiative
In effect 2012–Present
- 2012–2014: Electricity, Industrial Facilities
- 2015 onward: Electricity, Transportation, Buildings, Industrial Facilities
Price at Latest Auction
$17.00/metric ton CO₂ (November 2019)
- 2013-2014: 163 to 160 million metric tons CO₂e (1.9% reduction)
- 2015-2020: 395 to 334 million metric tons CO₂e (15% reduction)
- 2021-2031: 321 to 194 million metric tons CO₂e (40% reduction)
The Western Climate Initiative (WCI) is an economy-wide cap-and-invest program currently linked between California and Quebec.
The first compliance period, beginning in 2013, was designed to regulate emissions from in-state electricity generation, electricity imports, large industrial facilities, and other stationary emissions sources. The second compliance period, beginning in 2015, expanded to include suppliers of natural gas, diesel, gasoline, and other fossil fuels to in-state users.
Allowance prices have fluctuated between $10.09 and $17.45 per metric ton CO₂ since program launch, raising over $12.5 billion USD for California Climate Investments and $3.8 billion CAD for Quebec’s Green Fund. Both jurisdictions direct these funds largely towards programs that further reduction greenhouse gases and produce other co-benefits.
California achieved their 2020 emissions target 4 years early in 2016, largely due to substantial reductions in electricity sector emissions. As part of California’s Scoping Plans, cap-and-trade was designed as a backstop through 2020, allowing complementary policies such as fuel efficiency standards, energy efficiency, and renewable portfolio standards to drive the majority of emissions reductions.
In 2017, California renewed the program through 2030 with a legislative supermajority. A 2017 updated Scoping Plans anticipates the program to contribute 38% of the reductions needed to achieve a 2030 target of 40% below 2020 levels.
WCI was first created in 2007, when the governors of Arizona, California, New Mexico, Oregon, and Washington signed the Western Regional Climate Action Initiative. By 2008, Montana and Utah joined the initiative, as well as the Canadian provinces British Columbia, Manitoba, Ontario and Quebec. Additional observers included Alaska, Idaho, Wyoming, Nevada, Colorado, and Kansas; the Canadian province of Saskatchewan, and the Mexican states Baja California, Chihuahua, Coahulia, Nuevo Leon, Sonora, and Tamaulipas.
The initiative aimed to collectively reduce regional emissions to 15% below 2005 levels by 2020, with a regional economy-wide cap-and-trade program as the centerpiece. The WCI also requires that states adopt GHG emission reduction targets, and implement an action plan with complementary policies to achieve these goals. States were also required to adopt California’s vehicle greenhouse gas emissions standards, and be a part of the Climate Registry, an organization that helps to measure and report greenhouse gas emissions.
By November 2011, due to the recession, changes in state leadership, and unsupportive legislatures, New Mexico, Arizona, Washington, Oregon, Montana, and Utah all formally declined to participate in WCI, leaving Canada and four Canadian provinces as the remaining participants. California and Quebec followed through with a linked cap-and-trade program in 2013. In 2017, Ontario linked cap-and-trade programs with California and Quebec, but ended the program in July 2018 following a change in executive leadership.
Read More About State-Level Action in the WCI Region on our SCPN Page
Read our Latest Coverage on WCI
This webinar is part of the State Carbon Pricing Network’s Deep Dive Webinar Series. Each month, we explore a carbon pricing topic in depth, bringing in experts and pushing forward the conversation. Last week, six Democratic presidential candidates met in South...
This article is part 5 in a series on carbon pricing, environmental justice, and California’s cap-and-trade program. Check out our other articles in the series: Addressing Community Needs through Smart Climate Policy (9/27/19) Clearing the Air: Local Pollution as a Social Justice...
Offsets are among the most controversial and confusing topics in environmental policy, one that has been widely debated in the context of California’s cap-and-trade program. The very idea is quite polarizing. Offsets offer polluters mechanisms to pay for carbon solutions...